Boston Roofing Company

Roof Repair or Roof Replacement? Here’s Our Guide

All roofings have a lifespan. If your roof is damaged, it might be challenging to determine whether repairs are okay or you need a total replacement. It’s best to choose the right course of action because the consequences of otherwise are grave.

If your roof only needs repairs, replacing it is an unnecessary expense. Whereas, if you only repaired a roof that badly needs a replacement, the chances are high that it will ultimately collapse. You can also ask for professional advice from roofing companies. 

Here are five things that help you determine whether you need roof repairs or the more costly roofing replacement:

Roof age

Your roof age and its corresponding material is a primary indicator of roof replacement. Different roof materials have various lifespans based on their material science. For example, asphalt singles only have life service between 15 and 30 years. If your roof with asphalt shingles reached past the 15-year mark, the odds that you require replacement already are high.

Remember that although your old roof only sustained small damages, once it has reached past its peak conditions, its degradation rapidly accelerates. Consult with your commercial roofing contractors to help you decide if repairs are still worth it for your old roof.


Small leaks can be a sign of a bigger problem lurking above your ceiling. Sometimes, the problem is already widespread that an accumulation of water might make your roof collapse and flood your entire house. At the first sign of leakage, isolate the leaking point to prevent further damage. If there are multiple spots in your roof where the leakage is evident, it is best to ask your roofing contractor for a replacement.

Plans of moving out

If you don’t plan to stay in your home for the long-term, it is best to do repairs. Repairs are sufficient if you want to sell your home, but remember to be truthful to prospects when they ask for your roof’s condition. You might be held liable for your claims.

Consider layering over new shingles

Putting a new layer of shingles helps curb down the roofing costs. Sometimes old shingles are the problem, and the structural integrity of your roof deck is still intact. In this scenario, it is best to replace shingles instead of replacing your entire roof. 

Expect costs for other projects

Roof replacement has associated tasks that always come in a package with the replacement—those are gutter replacement and damage to the landscape. If you’re planning to push through with the roof replacement, remember that you also need to incorporate the costs of the mentioned activities. Consult with your roofing company to estimate a comprehensive analysis of the entirety of the project.

Cost-benefit analysis

Although repairs are cheaper than replacements, they only serve a temporary purpose. Similarly, roof replacements are expensive but can last for another three decades. Consider these when your roofing needs to get fixed. 


Roof damage can be caused by your community’s weather or your roof’s innate structural integrity. Both roof repairs or roof replacement can solve your problem. It would help if you ask roofing contractors for advice. 

We are a roofing company in Methuen, Massachusetts. Get in touch with us today and see how we can help with your roofing problem!

Leave a Comment

Call Now ButtonCall now!